Why the poor do not participate in microcredit programs
Self-exclusion
The poorest, especially
the poorest women, often lack confidence, skills, and market contacts. They
deem themselves
unable
to repay debt. This may be particularly relevant for women, who may have
limited control over the revenues used for repayment.
Shortage of time
Borrowers must incur the opportunity cost of weekly meetings and
other program demands on time. These activities, however valuable, take time
away from important domestic tasks as well as other remunerative activities.
Some of the poorest people, such as destitute single mothers with sick
children, as well as mothers with young children, may not participate because
they cannot afford the time demands of weekly meetings.
peer group exclusion
Peer groups (as well as staff) may have a
tendency to exclude those most likely to experience repayment difficulties.
While donors tend to view the poor as homogeneous, during the process of
self-selection, group members will filter out those who represent the greatest
risk for the group (Montgomery 1996, Hulme and Mosley, 1996; Noponen, 1990) and
may also include wealthier individuals for social reasons. (Hassan 1997).
High loan floors
As little as $50 can be too much for many
first-time borrowers. Yet microcredit programs often have official or
unofficial minimum loan sizes (R.I. Rahman, 1997). Some caution the propensity
to impose minimum loan amounts may raise with increased emphasis on financial
performance. A stronger emphasis on financial viability could lead to greater
pressure to give larger loans, as opposed to smaller loans where administrative
costs are proportionally much higher.